CMS Made Simple Forums

I need the opinion of you, the forum members. Most of you are webdesigners or at least people who know something about the web. We are having a serious discussion about two designs. First of all, a custom made one which you can see in the picture



Secondly this one:
http://www.egsites.be/

Which design is the best one and which would you recommend? Try to give points on a scale from 1 - 10 for each design.